pedal.ly

Facebook Instagram

How to Start Your First Band as a Guitarist: A No-B.S. Guide to Building Something Real

So, you’re a guitarist and you’re ready to start your first band – I’ve been there and done that. From my first high school hair metal rock band to turning 50 and being in a blues jamming band with guys in the 70s – I’ve been in a handful of bands over the years.

It might start with you having some riffs stacked up, a few covers under your fingers, or just that itch to make some noise with other people. But building a band isn’t just about grabbing a bassist and a drummer and jamming in someone’s garage. If you want something that lasts — and actually sounds good — there’s more to it. Let’s break it down.

It all starts with a vision, not just a vibe
Before you hit up Craigslist a Facebook band group or your local jam night, ask yourself:

  • What kind of music do I want to play? (Genres, influences, energy)
  • What’s the endgame? (Weekend gigs? Original recordings? Touring someday?)
  • Do I want this to be a democracy or my vision with collaborators?
    Write this down. It’ll help you communicate clearly when recruiting and avoid future conflict.


It’s all about the right people
Here’s where a lot of new bands crash and burn — bad fits.

You need:

  • Musical compatibility – Taste and skill levels should be in the same galaxy.
  • Commitment alignment – Don’t join forces with someone who wants to jam once a month if you’re trying to gig every weekend.
  • No ego-trippers – Look for people who listen as much as they play.


Where to look:

  • Local open mics and jam nights
  • Facebook groups (try “Phoenix Musicians,” “AZ Metalheads,” etc.)
  • Bandmix.com or Bandfinder.com
  • Local music stores (some still have bulletin boards!)
  • School or college music departments
  • The lesson studio you take lessons at
  • Networking with other musicians


The Secret Sauce: Communication
Once you’ve got a crew, set clear expectations early.

Talk about:

  • Practice frequency and location
  • Song selection (covers vs. originals)
  • Financial stuff (gear, rehearsal spaces, paid gigs)
  • Band branding and style
  • Social media, recordings, and gig goals


Pro tip: Use a group chat or a Band Google Doc to keep things organized.

Define your style without being a clone
Don’t stress about having every sound figured out.

Instead:

  • Create a shared playlist of inspiration songs
  • Pick 3–5 “anchor bands” that represent your sound
  • Record early rehearsals to review your evolving style


Think of it like seasoning. Your band’s style should reflect each member’s flavor — but too many flavors = chaos. Stay intentional.

Band killing pitfalls to avoid

  • Recruiting only friends (they may not have the chops or drive)
  • Avoiding hard conversations (nothing kills a band faster)
  • Practicing without purpose – Don’t just jam. Rehearse with a plan.
  • Overbooking before you’re ready – Your first show should be a debut, not a disaster.


Pro Tips from the Trenches

  • Record everything. Even phone recordings help track progress.
  • Get a band name and brand style early, but don’t stress over it too much.
  • Invest in a decent rehearsal space. Vibe matters.
  • Play with people better than you. It levels you up fast.
  • Celebrate small wins. First finished song. First tight set. First show.


Starting your first band is part musical experiment, part relationship juggling act. Expect some turnover, growing pains, and maybe the occasional blown amp. But when the pieces click – there’s nothing like it!

So get clear on your vision, find your people, rehearse with intention — and don’t forget why you started: to make great music and have a blast doing it!

Join the Pedal.ly Community! 
Looking for inspiration, gear tips and more? Follow us on Instagram or Facebook or join our Newsletter (Bonus – Get 5% off your next order). We’re all about helping players like you keep the passion alive.